You’ll Like What the Readers of Broken Wheel Recommend

9781492623441-300 (1)I read the most delightful book over Christmas! The Readers of Broken Wheel Recommend first came to my attention when I read Claire’s review of it. I thought it sounded like a wonderful comfort read, and it absolutely is. It is a feel-good book that has depth to it and is sure to make any book aficionado frequently nod with enthusiasm.

The main characters, Sara and Amy, meet via a book-swapping website, and through their letters and the books they exchange they become friends. When Sara, who lives in Sweden, loses her job, Amy, who lives in Broken Wheel, Iowa, invites her to visit. And contrary to her nature, Sara takes a plunge and goes to meet her friend in person. Remembering Amy’s vivid letters, Sara has no trouble recognizing the people she meets in Broken Wheel, although things are definitely different from what she had expected. Because of various events and circumstances, Sara finds herself tending to a new bookstore in town. It is an easy way for her to get to know the people who live in Broken Wheel, and soon she feels at home in this Midwestern small town. There are a number of quirky characters, and not all of them know what to do with Sara, the new store, or even the books they find inside. Yet slowly but surely, people come together to make the most of their one and only visitor and the possibility of their town’s revival, which seems to have arrived with Sara.

I truly enjoyed reading this book. There are a lot of references to other books in this one; the author must be a passionate reader herself. I loved that these references included everything from Harry Potter to Iris Murdoch. Even The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Society was mentioned, a book I was reminded of while reading. The love story in this book felt a little rushed to me. However, I am willing and eager to overlook that because I finally found a slightly awkward character who does not magically become graceful only because she has suddenly found her love interest. She remained true to character throughout the entire story, which was wonderfully refreshing.

If you are not sure whether you might like this book, answer the following to find out:

  1. Do you sometimes get so lost in your reading that you completely forget your surroundings?
  2. Do you enjoy the smell of new books (and can you smell the difference between paperbacks and hardcovers)?
  3. Do you sometimes wish your guests would leave because you desperately want to finish your current read?
  4. The first time you read Persuasion, were you slightly disappointed because it is not Pride & Prejudice, but after rereading it a couple of times, you now like Persuasion better?
  5. Do you frequently contemplate reorganizing your book shelves because you are convinced there’s a better way to display your books?
  6. Do you spend too much time looking for books for the friend who claims to be an absolute non-reader?
  7. Do you often make ambitious lists of books to read, only to get distracted by other books as soon as your list is finished?
  8. Do you sometimes prefer fictional characters to actual people?
  9. Do you sometimes wish you worked in a bookstore, because then you “could read all the books, all the time”?
  10. Do you like chocolate?

If you answered “yes” to just one of these questions, you will enjoy reading about Sara and Broken Wheel.

I received a copy of this book via Netgalley. The publisher, Sourcebooks, is running a giveaway for the book, and you can enter it here. And because this book celebrates the independent bookstore, you can nominate your favorite one here, and Sourcebooks will award the winning bookstore with $3,000. Now go and put this book on your TBR list. Or better yet, start reading right away.



  1. I’ve been debating about this book, because the description seemed like my kind of thing, but it also seemed somehow average – perhaps because it does remind me so much of Guernsey, it seems done already. Your review reminds me of how much I do love a good book about books though!

    I recently read Uprooted by Naomi Novik and something I enjoyed about it was that the heroine in that book was also a bit clumsy and no better than average looking and the adventure and romance that followed didn’t magically change that.

    • I’ll have to check out Uprooted; thanks for the tip. That’s the one thing that often turns me off love stories: the awkward heroine suddenly shines, for no realistic reason.
      I hope you give Broken Wheel a try; even if it’s a bit predictable, it’s still a very nice book about books.

  2. As a book sniffer, I am definitely going to read this book. I first heard about it when a few people said they kept calling it The Readers of Book Wheel Recommend, which left me instantly intrigued. I’m glad the book is as good as I hoped!

  3. Sometimes you just need a feel-good comfort read, especially in the dark days of winter! It sounds as though it might make a good present for a certain kind of book lover… I can think of at least one friend who would love it.

  4. hahahaha I really enjoyed your list of questions at the end. So many of those ring true.
    I felt mostly the same about this when I read it. It is absolutely a comfort read for readers. I didn’t think that the romantic angle was necessary really, but you could see it coming a mile away. I agree that, if it had to be done, it was rushed. But, like you, I was willing to move past it because the rest of it was so delightful.

    • I’m glad you enjoyed the book as well. It was perfect to be read over the busy holidays. I got a kick out of the whole marrying for a visa issue, because even though my situation has always been different, plenty of people have asked me over the years why I don’t just get a Green Card or US citizenship, as if it’s as easy as that.

  5. I’ve been seeing this book around lately and it reminds me a bit of The Storied Life of AJ Fikry, which I loved. It’s also nice to have a feel-good book to recommend, as I get requests for that a lot and never seem to have many good options, as I read a lot of dark stuff.

    • I haven’t read The Storied Life, so I can’t make a comparison, but from what I remember of other readers’ reviews, I would think that the sentiments behind both books are similar. And yes, it’s definitely a good recommendation for someone who is looking for a feel-good book.

  6. I answered yes to 9 out of 10 of your questions, so I guess I better read the book! I have actually owned it for a little while now, but haven’t read it yet because I’ve been afraid that it will disappoint me. So I’m relieved to hear that you liked it!
    I’m hoping that because it’s on your list that I’m not the only one who sometimes wishes my company away so that I can read my book instead. I feel a lot of guilt over that one. I’m also very guilty of #6 and #7 (but they aren’t quite as shameful).

    • It is definitely a feel-good book, and even if the story itself doesn’t do that much for you, I think you’ll like the way it’s presented, especially if you answered 9 out of 10 questions with yes. Those are all sentiments you’ll find in the story. (Uninvited guests in the middle of a good book are not a good mix…!)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s