This Godforsaken Place by Cinda Gault


Three years ago, we visited Quebec City, and one day, we took a day trip north, to Tadoussac, where the Saguenay River flows into the St. Lawrence River. It was beautiful, of course, and it all looked so vast to me. I was in awe; I wish I had better pictures to convey the overwhelming landscape. I kept imagining what the first settlers must have thought when they saw the land from their boat: the mountains like massive boulders and the seemingly endless woods.

These were the images I had in mind when I read Cinda Gault’s This Godforsaken Place (which takes place further west). It tells the story of emigrants Abigail and her father, who had been hired to teach English to settlers from Scandinavia. Neither Abigail nor her father had really planned ahead for their new life in Canada, and when her father unexpectedly dies from consumption, Abigail has two choices: She can take her father’s place in the school, marry the man who hired her father, and forever stay in town, OR she can fulfill a dying man’s last wish by bringing a large amount of money (of tainted origin) and a gun that once belonged to an employee of the Pinkerton Detective Agency to someone called Shea Wyatt, who is friends with Annie Oakley (the famous American sharpshooter).

Armed with a gun, a charming horse, and a vague sense of newfound freedom, Abigail sets out to travel to the United States to find Buffalo Bill Cody and become friends with Annie Oakley. She accomplishes both and gets hired to be a helper in Bill’s Wild West Show, moving to New York City and even to England with the show. However, things become complicated when Shea Wyatt is accused of murder, and Abigail has to decide exactly how far she is willing to go to get justice.

23168345I really enjoyed reading this book. It was a good story, and I learned quite a bit about Canadian history. Despite my interest in the exploration and settlement of America, my knowledge of Canadian history is sorely lacking. So it took me a while to understand how important the Metis Rebellion, Louis Riel, and Gabriel Dumont were to the book’s story. Then I had to read up online what exactly happened with this event and the people to follow along. I certainly didn’t mind that; after all, learning new stuff is one of the reasons I read. But I have to admit that there were times when I wished some things had been explained or described in a little more detail. Still, I consider this shortcoming to be mine, not the book’s.

Be that as it may, the underlying question is certainly a fascinating one: in a fledgling society, determined to do things  “better,” how much does the fate of the individual matter? And should an individual be willing to accept injustice in the name of the greater good?

I have to thank Naomi for first bringing this book to my attention. I had already resolved to purchase this book for my birthday when I was offered a free review copy by Brindle & Glass. So thank you to them as well. This book has certainly rekindled an interest in Canadian history.




  1. I completely missed your review and then I saw it on the Brindle & Glass website. So wonderful to hear your personal connection to the story’s setting. I completely understood Abigail’s decision to leave as well because it was clear she had an adventurous spirit. I agree with you that it took learning how to use a gun and the death of her father to make up her mind. I think seeking justice was just an excuse she used to rationalize such a risky choice.

  2. I haven’t picked this up yet, but Naomi’s review also caught my attention! It’s fun that you had personal experience to draw on when picturing the setting of this book 🙂

  3. Apart from Jack London and Fennimore Cooper I don’t think I’ve read any works set in “wild north”. Your review makes this seem an attractive read. I’ve made a note of the author.

  4. Sounds intriguing! It must be tricky for writers of historical fiction to know how much background info to include. Too little, and a reader might feel a bit lost – too much, and it can slow the story down to a crawl. I must admit I like there to be enough in the book to stop me feeling as if I have to look things up elsewhere,,, because I’m a pretty lazy reader!

    • I think this is definitely a Canadian book, where a certain knowledge of the historical events is helpful to follow the story of the book. I still don’t have a good idea of how big this was in Canadian history, so my reading experience was probably not as rich as someone’s who already knows about the events.

  5. Beautiful review, TJ! I love that you included the photos and story about your trip to Quebec. It is awe-inspiring to look out over the cliffs and water and imagine what it would have been like many years ago. I often go back even further than the first European settlers and imagine what it would have been like before they came. So peaceful.
    I have to admit, I questioned her decision to find justice – my thought was that she would have a hard time back then to find people who cared enough to help her. I wondered why she didn’t consider using some of the money to go back to England. But, it made a good story. I did feel bad for Lars – he seemed like a nice guy. 🙂
    Thanks for linking to my review! And, I’m glad you liked the book!

    • I could actually understand her decision to leave; as you pointed out in your review, learning how to shoot gave her the confidence to set out on her own, since she wasn’t keen on staying with Lars. But I was a bit unconvinced by her insistence to keep pushing once her attorney told her that people might not believe her story about the money and the Pinkerton gun. Money and guns are never a good combination. 🙂 Still, I liked the story overall.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s