Carson McCullers: The Ballad of the Sad Café

balladThe dictionary defines a ballad as “any light, simple song, especially one of sentimental or romantic character, having two or more stanzas all sung to the same melody.” While there is no singing in this novella and the story is anything but simple, I find the title fitting. It is easy to imagine this being turned into a song. The writing is lyrical, full of imagery and astute observations. The story of a twisted love triangle is sad and left me feeling a bit melancholic.

The three characters in the love triangle are Miss Amelia, a masculine woman who knows good liquor and remedies for all ailments except “female complaints”; Marvin Macy, her husband of less than a week who left and ended up in prison; and Cousin Lymon, a manipulative dwarf with the talent to offend and entertain at the same time. Marvin Macy loves Miss Amelia, Miss Amelia loves Cousin Lymon, and Cousins Lymon loves Marvin Macy. While each is passionate in his/her way, not one shows much compassion. Each character is flawed and weird, yet also completely human.

McCullers does a brilliant job conjuring up the somewhat downtrodden inhabitants of a sleepy Southern town where neighbors watch each other because they have nothing better to do. The tension slowly builds as people unhurriedly wait for the conflict between the three main characters to come to a head.

“There were times when Miss Amelia seemed to go into a sort of trance. And the cause of these trances was usually known and understood. For Miss Amelia was a fine doctor, and did not grind up swamp roots and other untried ingredients and give them to the first patient who came along; whenever she invented a new medicine she always tried it out first on herself. […] Often, when there was a sudden keen gripe, she would stand quite still, her queer eyes staring down at the ground and her fists clenched; she was trying to decide which organ was being worked upon, and what misery the new medicine might be most likely to cure. And now, as she watched the hunchback and Marvin Macy, her face wore this same expression, tense with reckoning some inward pain, although she had taken no new medicine that day. […] Marvin Macy folded the knife he had been honing, and after looking about him fearlessly he swaggered out of the yard. The embers in the pit were turning to gray feathery ashes and it was now quite dark.”

At first glance, it might seem odd to explore a theoretically beautiful feeling like love and have it depicted by slightly grotesque characters. But in McCuller’s story, love itself becomes grotesque. The reader is reminded of all the twisted forms that love can take on. The story ends with the ultimate betrayal, and love remains unrequited.

Reading The Story of the Sad Café has put me in the mood for more Southern Gothic literature. I’m glad I have Flannery O’Connor’s Wise Blood on my TBR Pile challenge.



  1. Clock Without Hands is the only McCullers novel I’ve read so far, but I’d like to try another at some stage. She does seem to bring a sense of humanity and compassion to her stories.

    • I haven’t read anything other than this one by McCullers. But just based on that, it seems that there’s a little more humanity in her writing than in Flannery O’Connor’s books, for example. I enjoyed this twisted tale.

  2. This book sounds as sad as its title. And kind of strange, too. But, sometimes I really want a good, sad book, so I will put it on the sad book list! 🙂

      • It would be fun to take a picture of, except it is mostly in list form, and they are scattered with the word ‘sad’ written next to them so I can easily find one when I want to. Ha. I sound like a strange person. 🙂

  3. I can’t remember what prompted me to buy this – but I did about a year ago. I read an incredible review of it somewhere and bought it right away. And of course, like all books I’d like to read immediately – it still sits on my shelves unread. 😀 I enjoyed your review, and hopefully I’ll get to it soon! I like what you said about it making you crave more Southern Gothic literature – it’s such a wonderful genre, isn’t it?

    • I did the same thing… bought the book after reading a great review. And then, when I finally got around to reading the story, I couldn’t even find my own book and had to go borrow it from the library. 🙂 And yes, Southern Gothic literature is wonderful.

  4. Mm, I don’t know if I’ll get around to reading this one, but I see what you mean about its potential as a song. It seems like something a bard would spin in a tavern.

    Glad you enjoyed!

  5. […] 1. The Ballad of the Sad Café, Carson McCullers 2. Wise Blood, Flannery O’Connor 3. The Things They Carried, Tim O’Brien 4. The Marquise of O, Heinrich von Kleist 5. The Jews‘ Beech Tree, Annette von Droste-Huelshoff 6. Tess of the d’Urbervilles, Thomas Hardy 7. Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy, John LeCarre […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s